/*
- * $Id: dbd_lookup.c,v 1.11 2009-11-25 14:59:15 franklahm Exp $
+ * $Id: dbd_lookup.c,v 1.18 2010-01-19 14:57:11 franklahm Exp $
*
* Copyright (C) Joerg Lenneis 2003
* Copyright (C) Frank Lahm 2009
/*
CNID salvation spec:
-general rule: better safe then sorry, so we always delete CNIDs and assing
-new ones in case of a lookup mismatch.
+general rule: better safe then sorry, so we always delete CNIDs and assign
+new ones in case of a lookup mismatch. afpd also sends us the CNID found
+in the adouble file. In certain cases we can use this hint to determince
+the right CNID.
The lines...
Possible solution:
None. Delete old data, file gets new CNID in both cases (rename and inode).
+If we got a hint and hint matches the CNID from devino we keep it and update
+the record.
2) UNIX mv from one folder to another
----------------------------------------
- didname
Possible solution:
-strcmp names, if they match keep CNID.
+strcmp names, if they match keep CNID. Unfortunately this also can't be
+distinguished from a new file with a reused inode. So me must assign
+a new CNID.
+If we got a hint and hint matches the CNID from devino we keep it and update
+the record.
+
+3) Restore from backup ie change of inode number -- or emacs
+------------------------------------------------------------
-3) Restore from backup
-----------------------
15 2 f 1 1 file
-->
15 2 f 1 2 file
+ didname
Possible fixup solution:
-Update.
-
-4) emacs
---------
-emacs uses a backup file (file~). When saving because of inode reusage of the fs,
-both files exchange inodes.
-
-General case for inode reusage:
-15 2 f 1 1 file
--->
-16 2 f 1 1 new_file_with_reused_inode
+test-suite test235 tests and ensures that the CNID is _changed_. The reason for
+this is somewhat lost in time, but nevertheless we believe our test suite.
-Result in dbd_lookup:
-+ devino
-- didname
+Similar things happen with emas: emacs uses a backup file (file~). When saving
+because of inode reusage of the fs, both files most likely exchange inodes.
-Emacs case:
15 2 f 1 1 file
16 2 f 1 2 file~
--> this would be nice:
15 2 f 1 2 file
16 2 f 1 1 file~
---> but because we must follow the general case you get this:
+--> but for the reasons described above we must implement
17 2 f 1 2 file
18 2 f 1 1 file~
devino search and didname search result in different CNIDs !!
Possible fixup solution:
-to be safe we must implement the general case, sorry emacs.
+to be safe we must assign new CNIDs to both files.
*/
#ifdef HAVE_CONFIG_H
#include <string.h>
#include <sys/param.h>
#include <errno.h>
-#include <netatalk/endian.h>
+#include <arpa/inet.h>
+
#include <atalk/logger.h>
#include <atalk/cnid_dbd_private.h>
rply->namelen = 0;
rply->cnid = 0;
+
+ LOG(log_maxdebug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(): START");
buf = pack_cnid_data(rqst);
type_didname = ntohl(type_didname);
}
+ LOG(log_maxdebug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(name:'%s', did:%u, dev/ino:0x%llx/0x%llx) {devino: %u, didname: %u}",
+ rqst->name, ntohl(rqst->did), (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino, devino, didname);
+
/* Have we found anything at all ? */
if (!devino && !didname) {
/* nothing found */
}
/* Check for type (file/dir) mismatch */
- if (devino && (type_devino != rqst->type)) {
- /* one is a dir one is a file, remove from db */
- rqst->cnid = id_devino;
- if (! roflag)
- if (dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID) < 0)
- return -1;
- rply->result = CNID_DBD_RES_NOTFOUND;
- return 1;
- } else if (didname && (type_didname != rqst->type)) {
- /* same: one is a dir one is a file, remove from db */
- rqst->cnid = id_didname;
- if (! roflag)
- if (dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID) < 0)
- return -1;
+ if ((devino && (type_devino != rqst->type)) || (didname && (type_didname != rqst->type))) {
+
+ if (devino && (type_devino != rqst->type)) {
+ /* one is a dir one is a file, remove from db */
+
+ LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(name:'%s', did:%u, dev/ino:0x%llx/0x%llx): type mismatch for devino",
+ rqst->name, ntohl(rqst->did), (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
+
+ if (! roflag) {
+ rqst->cnid = id_devino;
+ rc = dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID);
+ rc += dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_IDX_DEVINO);
+ rc += dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_IDX_DIDNAME);
+ if (rc < 0) {
+ LOG(log_error, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(name:'%s', did:%u, dev/ino:0x%llx/0x%llx): error deleting type mismatch for devino",
+ rqst->name, ntohl(rqst->did), (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
+ return -1;
+ }
+ }
+ }
+
+ if (didname && (type_didname != rqst->type)) {
+ /* same: one is a dir one is a file, remove from db */
+
+ LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(name:'%s', did:%u, dev/ino:0x%llx/0x%llx): type mismatch for didname",
+ rqst->name, ntohl(rqst->did), (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
+
+ if (! roflag) {
+ rqst->cnid = id_didname;
+ rc = dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID);
+ rc += dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_IDX_DEVINO);
+ rc += dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_IDX_DIDNAME);
+ if (rc < 0) {
+ LOG(log_error, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(name:'%s', did:%u, dev/ino:0x%llx/0x%llx): error deleting type mismatch for didname",
+ rqst->name, ntohl(rqst->did), (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
+ return -1;
+ }
+ }
+ }
+
rply->result = CNID_DBD_RES_NOTFOUND;
return 1;
}
}
if (devino && didname && id_devino != id_didname) {
- /* CNIDs don't match, something of a worst case! */
+ /* CNIDs don't match, something of a worst case, or possibly 3) emacs! */
LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup: CNID mismatch: (DID:%u/'%s') --> %u , (0x%llx/0x%llx) --> %u",
ntohl(rqst->did), rqst->name, ntohl(id_didname),
(unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino, ntohl(id_devino));
- /* Something like 5), the emacs case (see above), remove it all */
if (! roflag) {
rqst->cnid = id_devino;
if (dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID) < 0)
}
if ( ! didname) {
- LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(DID:%u/'%s',0x%llx/0x%llx): CNID resolve problem: server side rename oder reused inode",
- ntohl(rqst->did), rqst->name, (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
- rqst->cnid = id_devino;
- /* Case 2) ? */
- if (strcmp(rqst->name, (char *)devdata.data + CNID_NAME_OFS) == 0) {
- LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup: server side mv from one dir to another");
+ LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(CNID hint: %u, DID:%u, \"%s\", 0x%llx/0x%llx): CNID resolve problem: server side rename oder reused inode",
+ ntohl(rqst->cnid), ntohl(rqst->did), rqst->name, (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
+ if (rqst->cnid == id_devino) {
+ LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup: server side mv (with resource fork)");
update = 1;
} else {
- if ( ! roflag)
+ if ( ! roflag) {
+ rqst->cnid = id_devino;
if (dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID) < 0)
return -1;
+ }
rply->result = CNID_DBD_RES_NOTFOUND;
return 1;
}
if ( ! devino) {
LOG(log_debug, logtype_cnid, "dbd_lookup(DID:%u/'%s',0x%llx/0x%llx): CNID resolve problem: changed dev/ino",
ntohl(rqst->did), rqst->name, (unsigned long long)rqst->dev, (unsigned long long)rqst->ino);
- rqst->cnid = id_didname;
- update = 1;
+ if ( ! roflag) {
+ rqst->cnid = id_didname;
+ if (dbd_delete(dbd, rqst, rply, DBIF_CNID) < 0)
+ return -1;
+ }
+ rply->result = CNID_DBD_RES_NOTFOUND;
+ return 1;
}
/* This is also a catch all if we've forgot to catch some possibility with the preceding ifs*/